Not too long ago, millennials killed breakfast cereal. (Allegedly.) Its grave had hardly settled when they dug it right back up again and zapped it back to life, transforming it into something Instagram-friendly, ubiquitous to podcast ads, and, supposedly, healthy. 

I am referring, of course, to Magic Spoon. The whimsical, hyper-colorful cereal brand promises a taste reminiscent of childhood with macros worthy of fueling a grown-up (or at least the kind of person who refers to the process of getting through their day as “adulting”). Can any such product live up to the hype? Magic Spoon sent me several boxes to try, and I set out to find the answer. After some thorough taste tests and interviews with two dietitians, I think that, yes, Magic Spoon is more or less healthy—with some key caveats.

Pssst: Ness Cardmembers can get money back¹ on Magic Spoon.

What Is Magic Spoon?

Magic Spoon is a cereal brand founded by Greg Sewitz and Gabi Lewis, two college friends-turned-entrepreneurs. (They met at Brown University, an unsurprising wellness incubator.)

All Magic Spoon cereals are high-protein, low-carb, grain-free, keto-friendly, and contain no added sugar. Its standard flavors range between 140 and 170 calories per each one-cup serving. The hook is that said flavors don’t exactly seem like they’d carry this nutrition profile: Each one sounds mouth-wateringly, tantalizingly sweet, with a clear analog to the cereals that aired commercials on repeat on Nickelodeon 20-odd years ago. There’s “Fruity,” “Frosted,” “Cocoa,” “Peanut Butter,” “Blueberry Muffin,” “Cinnamon Roll,” and “Maple Waffle.” If you’re unsure about which Magic Spoon flavor is supposed to correspond to which sugary cereal flavor, it’s all laid out on a page on its website titled “Us vs. Them.”

Where to Get Magic Spoon Cereal

To buy Magic Spoon cereal on its website, you can build a 4-pack for $39 ($29.25 for a monthly subscription) or a 6-pack for $59 ($44.25 for a monthly subscription). You can also buy a 4-pack on Amazon and some flavors at Target for $10 a box.

What Is Magic Spoon Cereal Made Of?

Cow’s milk protein blend—also known as whey protein Mayo Clinic “Whey Protein” View Source —is the first ingredient for each Magic Spoon flavor, which means it is not vegan or suitable for someone with a lactose intolerance. It is gluten-free, though. Other than that, it contains a mix of vegetable oils, tapioca flour (a gluten-free starch that comes from the cassava plant), chicory root (a prebiotic fiber), vegetable juice and/or turmeric NCCIH “Turmeric” View Source and spirulina extract for color, salt, and allulose and monk fruit for sweetness. 

Allulose Cleveland Clinic “What Is Allulose” View Source is a natural sweetener found in foods like raisins, wheat, and figs. It’s a little less sweet than sugar and is not absorbed by the body, so it doesn’t contribute to overall caloric intake. The sweetener is considered safe by the FDA, and initial studies Foods “Research Advances of d-allulose: An Overview of Physiological Functions, Enzymatic Biotransformation Technologies, and Production Processes” View Source indicate that it may have some anti-diabetic and anti-oxidation properties. However, research is limited, and studies that point to positive effects may not apply to everyone. One study Nutrients “Gastrointestinal Tolerance of D-Allulose in Healthy and Young Adults. A Non-Randomized Controlled Trial” View Source only evaluated healthy young adults and excluded anyone with asthma, gastrointestinal conditions, or who had recently gone through surgery. 

Monk fruit Scientific Reports “Introduction, adaptation and characterization of monk fruit (Siraitia grosvenorii): a non-caloric new natural sweetener” View Source is also a natural, plant-based sweetener that’s approved by the FDA. It’s a lot sweeter than regular sugar—the FDA FDA “Additional Information about High-Intensity Sweeteners Permitted for Use in Food in the United States” View Source considers it a “high-intensity sweetener”—so only a tiny amount is required to add a kick. Like allulose, it isn’t absorbed in the body and doesn’t contribute calories to a meal or food product. 

There’s nothing wrong with these pass-right-through sweeteners. But it’s a good idea to go easy if it’s your first time trying them. “With anything that isn’t absorbed by the body, you run the risk of some gastrointestinal issues—gas, bloating, or nausea,” says Alissa Rumsey, MS, RD, founder of Alissa Rumsey Nutrition & Wellness and author of Unapologetic Eating.

The presence of chicory root can also cause digestive discomfort, especially when consumed in high amounts. There isn’t a ton in Magic Spoon, but if you find yourself eating a whole box in one sitting, you may have to run to the bathroom, fast.

Is Magic Spoon Cereal Healthy?

As far as a nutrition profile goes, Magic Spoon is close to unimpeachable. Its protein content—12-14 grams per serving, depending on the flavor—rivals many protein bars and powders, and its lack of sugar is a real benefit for anyone who needs to lower their intake. “In my opinion, it is not lacking any ingredients,” says Sequoia Ridley, RDN. “Magic Spoon offers a good amount of macronutrients (carbohydrates, fat, and protein) as well as a decent amount of sodium and fiber.” These factors definitely help count it as healthier than the sugary-sweet cereals it’s mimicking.

In practice, it’s a little more complicated. The first thing to know is that, like the breakfast cereals of yore, it’s part of a balanced diet—not the whole thing. Ridley generally recommends that people eat fruit, vegetables, lean protein, whole grains, and low-fat dairy about 80% of the time. “Foods that are more processed, or ultra-processed, with additives such as sweeteners, protein powders, and added fibers, can make up that other 20%, which is where Magic Spoon would fall,” says Ridley. “I would suggest a client have Magic Spoon a couple times per week, but then the other days focus on whole foods.”

Because it’s low-calorie and low-carb, a bowl of Magic Spoon may not feel like enough for some people. It can be great as a snack, but if you’re having it as a meal, Rumsey recommends supplementing with some carbohydrates, like a piece of toast with peanut butter or a banana. “If someone is only having this for breakfast, they’re not going to be full or satisfied for very long,” she says. “We do need carbohydrates to help us feel full, they impact our appetite hormones in different ways than protein and fat. Carbohydrates help us stay full and satisfied and give us energy.”

How Does Magic Spoon Keep Its Carb Count Low?

Partial credit for Magic Spoon’s low carb number is due to its grain-free ingredient list. But it’s also because Magic Spoon calculates net carbs for each cereal flavor, which is the number you see on the front of the box. Net carbs are determined by taking the total grams of carbohydrates in a meal or food, then subtracting fiber and non-sugar sweeteners. The idea is that the body doesn’t absorb these ingredients, so they don’t impact blood sugar and thus don’t need to be counted.

Net carb theory is not endorsed by the FDA or American Diabetes Association. Still, it’s popular among people who follow paleo and keto diets. If you’ve been told to be mindful of carbohydrates, you may be better off checking the carb count on the nutrition label on the back of the box. (Usually about 15 grams compared to the 3 or 4 on the front.) Either way, if you feel better after eating a bowl of Magic Spoon than you do after some Frosted Flakes, the net carb count could be why.

Is Magic Spoon Actually Satisfying?

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Magic Spoon (@magicspooncereal)

Finally, there’s the mental phenomenon of eating something that appears to be one delicious, indulgent thing, but is just different enough that it doesn’t quite deliver. (Call it the Halo Top effect.) “What I often see happen with ice cream and other foods that have been ‘healthified’ is that they don’t actually taste the same as the original, and so they’re not as satisfying to people,” says Rumsey. “When we’re not satisfied, even if we’re feeling physically full, it’s easy to keep eating.”

To me, Magic Spoon tasted good enough that I felt satisfied when I ate it. (More on that in a sec.) But a person could, in theory, easily go through the day day eating packaged low-calorie facsimiles of other food—say, a bowl of Magic Spoon for breakfast, a cauliflower thins sandwich for lunch, powdered peanut butter and Popcorners for an afternoon snack, and spirulina-based Noodies ramen for dinner, followed by some Halo Top for dessert.

Of course, most people don’t do this. Still, it’s worth noting that if the replacement doesn’t work for you, it’s best not to force it, “If you really like the taste of it, go for it,” says Rumsey. “See if and how it affects your eating for the rest of the day and a couple of days after.” 

Basically: If you try it, and you actually like it, Magic Spoon will be both healthy and satisfying. If it leaves you cold, you may be better off with something else.

Is Magic Spoon Cereal Good?

I like it! I tried the Blueberry Muffin, Cocoa, Fruity, Frosted, and Cinnamon Roll flavors, and all of them tasted more or less like what I expected. For me, the fruit-inspired variations are the clear winners—the blueberry muffin tasted like, well, a blueberry muffin—but your mileage may vary depending on your own flavor preferences.

I will say that the experience did not give me the same feeling that diving into a bowl of Fruity Pebbles once did. This has to do with the taste. It’s not exactly less sweet than classic sugary cereal, but it’s a different kind of sweet. I’d also classify it as a little chewy rather than crunchy, likely because its base is milk protein rather than oats or corn. Still, it tasted like a pleasantly indulgent morning treat.

I also felt satisfied for a few hours after eating it—the same way I feel after eating some oatmeal. Most of the time, I found myself mixing Magic Spoon with the Grape-Nuts I already had in my cabinet. (My usual cereal tastes tend to veer on the geriatric side.) I recommend this to anyone who wants to cut the cereal’s sweetness. It also gave it a bit more crunch, and hewed to Rumsey’s recommendation to supplement Magic Spoon with another, carbier food. Plus, it made the box last longer. At about $10 a pop, that feels valuable.

Is Magic Spoon Cereal Worth It?

It’s also not necessary to opt for Magic Spoon just for a healthy breakfast. But for those who find themselves dreaming of the cereal of their youths, it’s worth trying a box. (Or four.) If it brings joy—even a little bit—that’s enough for us to call it healthy.

• 1 Access to a Ness Card account is subject to credit approval. You must be at least 18 years old (or the age of majority in your state) and reside in the continental US to apply. An approved Ness Card application will result in a hard credit inquiry, which may impact your credit score.